Skip to content
 

Evaluation of basic and long-term research within technology

The evaluation of basic and long-term research within technology was conducted in 2014. The evaluation included research groups from universities, university colleges and institutes. The results of the evaluation are summarized in three panel reports, and one overall report.

The evaluation's objectives are;

  • A critical review of technological research with an international perspective.
  • To obtain an international perspective on how the Norwegian research environments should face challenges within the field in the future.
  • Provide recommendations and actions to enhance the quality and efficiency of the research.
  • Serve as a foundation for strategic and subject-specific development within the individual research institutions.
  • Strengthen the Research Council's competence and grounds to advise the government and relevant departments in matters of research policy.

Key findings

Please see news item and the reports in the right column.

How the evaluation was conducted

The evaluation was conducted by three international panels of experts with 5-6 panel members. The three panel chairs have summarized the key findings in an overall report, in addition to the three panel reports.

  • Panel 1: Energy and Process Technology (including: Oil, gas, CO2, fluid mechanics, metallurgy for the process industry, electrical energy)
  • Panel 2: Products, Production, Project Management, Marine Systems and Renewable Energy (including: solar energy, bio energy, marine process technology, sensors and instrumentation/mechatronics, technology for fisheries and aquaculture)
  • Panel 3: Civil Engineering and Marine Structures (including: buildings, roads, water and wastewater engineering, structural mechanics)

The evaluation was based on three elements:  

  • A self-assessment submitted by the participating research environments based on an assessment template.
  • A bibliometric analysis of the scientific publications within the technology disciplines in Norway, and of the groups that were part of the evaluation. The analysis was carried out by NIFU.
  • Hearing meetings between the research groups and the panels. The meetings took place in Trondheim and Gardermoen in November 2014.

A total of 64 research environments/groups were part of the evaluation. The evaluation of technological research is the last to follow in the evaluation of the MNT- disciplines for this period of time. Previous evaluations include Chemistry (2009), Physics (2010), Geological Research (2011), Biology, Medicine and Health (2011), ICT (2012), and Mathematics (2012). The research groups from these evaluations were with a few exceptions not part of the evaluation of basic and long-term research within technology. The participating research environments came from 6 universities (NTNU, NMBU, UiB, UiS, UiA, UiT), 3 university colleges (Gjøvik, Østfold, Telemark) and 8 institutes (IFE, NGI, IRIS, MARINTEK, SINTEF Building and Infrastructure, SINTEF Materials and chemistry, SINTEF Energy, SINTEF Fisheries and aquaculture).

Follow-up of the evaluation

The follow-up of the evaluation involves all the institutions that were part of the evaluation. Some of the findings and recommendations are naturally addressed locally at the institutions, while others must be followed-up at a national level. National-level recommendations, or those common for several research communities or groups, will jointly be followed up by the institutions of higher education, the institute sector, the Research Council, and the ministries.

The Research Council invited the evaluated institutions and research communities to provide their suggestions on how to follow-up the findings and recommendations from the evaluation, either locally or nationally. The national-level suggestions were further treated by a follow-up committee appointed by the Research Council. The committee had eight members from the evaluated institutions, and were commissioned to give their recommendations on follow-up actions. The committee delivered its report in the spring of 2017. See right hand side of this page.

The Research Council is considering which concrete actions that should be initiated based on the evaluation and the follow-up report. Any grants or calls for proposals will be announced during the autumn of 2017.

The follow-up committee

  • Ernst Kristiansen, Vice President Research, SINTEF Digital (leader)
  • Helge Brattebø, Professor, Department of Energy and Process Engineering, NTNU
  • Cecilie Rolstad Denby, Dean, Faculty of Science and Technology, NMBU
  • Eva Dugstad, Director for Business Development at The Norwegian Radium Hospital Research Foundation
  • Martin Fernø, Associate Professor, Department of Physics and Technology, UiB
  • Randi Toreskås Holta, Vice Dean, Faculty of Technology, Natural Sciences and Maritime Sciences, HSN
  • May Britt Myhr, Head of Department, Department of Petroleum Engineering, UiS
  • Jostein Mårdalen, Head of Department, Department of Materials Science and Engineering, NTNU
Published:
28.04.2014
Last updated:
27.04.2017
Page Editor:
Karina Wethal Senior Executive Officer +47 22 03 70 13 kaw@forskningsradet.no